Rental ROI – The Four Returns

Most new landlords only track one return – monthly cash flow. That understates what your rental actually earns. Here are the four returns that make up your real ROI, with Arizona tax treatment built in.

Return #1 – Cash flow

Monthly cash left over after all expenses (mortgage, tax, insurance, HOA, management, maintenance reserve, vacancy reserve). The most visible return. Also the lowest, in percentage terms, for newer single-family rentals.

Monthly Cash Flow = Rent − (PITI + HOA + Mgmt + Maintenance + Vacancy)

On a typical Arizona single-family rental, year-1 cash flow on a 20%-down mortgage is ~0.5 – 2% of property value annually. See our Calculators page for worked examples.

Return #2 – Principal paydown

Every mortgage payment pays down a chunk of the loan. On a 30-year fixed, year-1 principal paydown is roughly 1.0 – 1.4% of the home value (depending on interest rate). Year 10 it’s ~2% and accelerating. This is money accumulating in your equity account that you don’t see in cash flow.

Return #3 – Appreciation

Long-term US home appreciation averages 3 – 4% per year over multi-decade windows. Arizona markets have historically matched or exceeded that. Important caveat: appreciation is levered – if you put 20% down, a 4% market gain is a 20% gain on your equity. That’s how modest-looking appreciation creates large wealth over time.

Return #4 – Tax benefits

Rental real estate gets three federal tax advantages:

Depreciation: You write off the building (not the land) over 27.5 years. On a $400K home with a $320K building value, that’s ~$11,600 of annual depreciation – a non-cash deduction that often turns a positive-cash-flow property into a paper loss for tax purposes.

Deductible expenses: Mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, management fees, maintenance, HOA, travel to the property, and more.

1031 exchange option: When you sell, you can defer all capital gains by rolling proceeds into another investment property. No tax due until you eventually cash out.

Arizona’s 2.5% flat income tax is among the lowest in the country. Combined with the 25% long-term capital gains subtraction on post-2011 assets, the effective AZ tax drag on a rental is modest.

Putting it together – realistic year-1 ROI

Example: $400K Arizona single-family, 20% down ($80K cash in + $8K closing = $88K invested), $2,400/mo rent.

Component Year-1 value % of cash invested
Cash flow $2,000 2.3%
Principal paydown $5,200 5.9%
Appreciation (at 4%) $16,000 18.2%
Tax savings (depreciation × 24% fed bracket) $2,784 3.2%
Total year-1 return on $88K $25,984 29.5%

Real number for your property will vary with rate, leverage, rent, appreciation rate, and tax bracket. These are illustrative only.

Why cash flow gets overweighted

Cash flow is what hits your bank account, so it feels like ‘the return.’ But principal paydown and appreciation are usually 3 – 5× larger than cash flow on a newer property. Ignoring them leads to bad decisions – selling properties that are quietly earning 20%+ because the cash flow ‘only’ breaks even.

Want your specific numbers?

We’ll pull comps, estimate rent, and run the full four-return model for your property.

Get a free ROI analysis

This page is provided for informational purposes only and is not legal, tax, or investment advice. Statute citations are current as of April 2026 but laws change – consult a licensed attorney or CPA in Arizona before acting on any specific situation.